Photo Contests

Halloween Photo Contest
Adoptive Families 2017 Halloween Photo Contest
Share photos of your kids in costume!

Mommy Moments Photo Contest
2017 Mommy Moments Photo Contest
Meet the winners, Mae and her mom, and the finalists.

Daddy Moments Photo Contest
2017 Daddy Moments Photo Contest
Meet the winners, Annalyse and her dad, and the finalists.

Goofy Grins Photo Contest
2017 Goofy Grins Photo Contest
Meet the winner, Yuchen, and the finalists.

Kids & Pets Photo Contest
2017 Kids & Pets Photo Contest
Meet the winners, Hennie and her pups, and the finalists.

Adoption Blog: Improv Mom

An Adoptive Mom’s Movie Review of Lion



Okay, this post isn’t actually a review of the Oscar-nominated movie Lion. It’s more like—here’s what deeply moved this adoptive mama after watching, tissue box in hand, the true story of Saroo. This little boy from a tiny village in India fell asleep on a train, became lost, and was eventually adopted by an Australian couple. As a young man, remarkably, he found his way back to his first family. So, here’s what stayed with me long after my tears had dried and I could finally breathe through my nose again….

The Love.

So much love from Saroo’s first family. Yes, they were poor, lacking food, running water, medical care, schooling…. Yet, even in the face of this extreme poverty, the love and devotion of this family was palpable. And it made me think about the comments that we, adoptive families, hear about our adopted children—“She’s so lucky!” or “Can you imagine what his life could have been like?” Perhaps our kids wouldn’t have the same financial resources, or stability, or educational opportunities, or, in some cases, the attention and care had they stayed with their biological families. Yet these gains, while significant and meaningful, cannot override the fundamental loss of growing up apart from one’s biological family. Every scene of Saroo with his brother or his mother cried out to me how important it is for adoptive families to acknowledge the love, the good, or something positive if you find yourself struggling with “love” or “good,” that comes from our kids’ birth families. It could be as simple as, “You have the same beautiful smile as your birth mom.” Find the love. Value the love. Voice the love. Often.

The Guilt.

Oy vey, so much guilt. I could easily see how an adoptee could grow up feeling that they should be grateful to their adoptive parents for “rescuing” them, and feel guilty about searching for or having a relationship with their birth family. There was an emotional scene between Saroo and his adoptive mom, Sue, when she explains her “calling” to adopt Saroo and his brother:

“We both felt the world had more than enough people in it already. Because to have a child—that’s no guarantee that’s going to make things better. But to take a child who’s suffering—like you boys were—and to give him a chance in the world. Well, then. Now there’s something.”

My face was cringing through this part. I think the primary reason to adopt is to become a parent, not to save a child. Even if “helping a child in need” was on your short-list of reasons to adopt, once you adopt you realize—it’s the child who has added immeasurable meaning and merit to your life. Yes, there are specific circumstances that led to our children being placed for adoption and some of those reasons could be life threatening. And sure, we want our kids to cultivate gratitude just like any other non-serial-killing member of society. However, as adoptive parents, regardless of how our children came to us, why would we ever want our kids to feel like they owe us a depth of gratitude for adopting them? Guilty feelings don’t serve our children.

The Lack of Talking.

It seems that talking about adoption, or culture, or ethnicity wasn’t something that occurred all too often between Saroo and his parents. It downright shocked me when a college-aged Saroo said, “I’m not really Indian.” I believe that, if he and his family had talked more, had had more childhood experiences involving his Indian heritage and culture, Saroo would have benefited greatly. Talking regularly about his adoption story might have given Saroo the confidence to confide in his parents about his need to find his birth family. His adoptive parents, who are portrayed as loving and engaged, might actually been able to help, or, at the very least, would have been an incredible source of comfort and support to their son. It hurt my heart to see Saroo search on his own; to see Saroo stop his life, at time when his adult life was just beginning, to begin processing and talking about his adoption.

Is this film worth seeing? Most definitely. It’s a simple, poignant story, beautifully told. And it does an excellent job of shedding light on the complexities of growing up adopted. See it. Then let me know what you thought.


Related Posts on AdoptiveFamiliesCircle

2 Comments

Hi Barbara,

I actually heard the book (Audible) before I knew there was going to be a movie.  I loved the book.  There are a few differences from the movie.  Saroo had a 2nd biological brother that is not mentioned.  The portray the adoptive parents as being open about his adoption, and they mention that he had a map of India on his wall as a child.  In the book he does his search on his own over a span of 5 years!  The book is called A Long Way Home.

Anyway, back to the movie, I loved it!  I was so impressed with the little boy that plays Saroo.  I loved the cinematography, the positive portrayal of adoption, and the love that he has for his birth family that endures over the years.  The movie sends a strong message about the importance of birth family to an adopted child.  Definitely worth seeing!

By Deb on Thursday, February 23, 2017 at 9:39 pm.

Hi Deb,

I want to read the book now! I felt the same about the performances—that kid should have been nominated!

By Barbara Herel on Friday, February 24, 2017 at 6:37 pm.

Post a Comment

{headline}

Commenting is available to registered members only. Please log in or create an account.

Meet the Author

Barbara Herel

Barbara Herel

New York

I have recently adopted or am adopting from...
U.S. Newborn

View Profile »


NATIONAL ADOPTION DIRECTORY


Find an Adoption Agency

Find an Adoption Attorney or Agency



Search the full directory ►




Recent Adoption Blog Comments