New Contest

Mommy & Me Photo Contest
Adoptive Families 2013 Mommy and Me Photo Contest
Share your memorable mother-child scenes!

AF Cover Photo Contest
Adoptive Families 2013 Cover Photo Contest
Your most stunning shot could appear on our cover!

First Family Photos Contest
2013 First Family Photos Adoption Photo Contest Winner
Meet the winner, Maleigha (18 mos., U.S.), and the finalists.

Winter Fun Photo Contest
2013 Winter Fun Adoption Photo Contest Winner
Meet the winner, Calvin (18 mos., Korea), and the finalists.

Adoption Blog: Improv Mom

“She’s So Lucky”



A recent post posing the question, "how do you respond when people praise you for adopting?" has resonated deeply with me. When we first brought our newborn daughter home from Indiana, a "She's so lucky" comment from anyone would elicit an emphatic, even aggressive, "No, we're the lucky ones" in response. Why did it agitate me so? I believe it's because most people assume that a child who was adopted was unwanted and unloved by the birth family, and that, by bringing this child into my life, I have done something extraordinary.

I'll confess that, when first considering whether open domestic adoption was the right choice for my husband and me, the idea of "Helping a baby in need" made my very short reasons-for-adopting list. It came after 1) I WANT A BABY! and 2) Everyone deserves to know his or her birth-family history.
 
Of course, as soon as I started talking to potential birthmothers, this idea of "helping" went right out the window. In reality, open domestic adoption would help me achieve my dream of becoming a mother, plain and simple. And there's nothing particularly praiseworthy about that. It only takes speaking to a woman who has decided to make an adoption plan for her child to realize who's performing a noble deed and deserves the accolades here. Even so, three years into motherhood, I now react differently to the phrase "she's so lucky." It happened after hearing it from someone unexpected -- my daughter's biological grandmother.
 
It was last year, during our return visit to Indiana. After spending the day with Beth's biological mom, Kim, and Kim's family, my husband and I took everyone out to dinner. As the long day came to a close and Beth was giving hugs and saying goodbye, Kim's mother, the matriarch of the family, looked me in the eyes and said, "She's so lucky."
 
Why did this comment now bring me such joy? I believe the reason is simple. Here's a woman who has pictures of our daughter prominently displayed on her living room wall, alongside the rest of her grandchildren. I know she loves and misses Beth. Yet she knows that it takes more than love and wanting a child to actually raise one. She knows that this child, our Beth, was better off in our family than in hers. While Beth would be loved and wanted, she wouldn't have the care, the attention, the security, and, perhaps, the opportunities in life if she were not with us.
 
Beth is lucky -- like any child, adopted or not -- because she has parents who are engaged in her life.
 
I think about how lucky Beth is every time she and I sit down to do a nebulizer treatment for her asthma. Or when she's reading (her version of) The Cat in the Hat to me, or when my husband lets her stir the pancake batter. And I think about how lucky Beth is that she has family and friends in New York, New Jersey, Massachusetts, and Indiana who love her very much.
 
I am grateful she's so lucky -- because that makes me the luckiest mother alive.


Related Posts on AdoptiveFamiliesCircle

12 Comments

Love this!!!!  My husband and I truly are the lucky ones here… But it’s true—my son is so very lucky that so many people love him.  It’s definitely been a whirlwind of emotions along the way and I love how you really succintly summarized this aspect.  smile

By Kelly-O on Tuesday, March 06, 2012 at 6:36 pm.

Love the post, thanks for sharing!
http://www.adoptionhelp.org

By IAC on Thursday, March 08, 2012 at 5:41 pm.

Oh, thanks so much for your comments! I do appreciate it. ~ Barbara

By Barbara Herel on Monday, March 12, 2012 at 3:01 pm.

Thank you so much for sharing!  Our family has been having a hard time with this during our recent adoption.  I, too regularly get on my soap box in support of the very difficult, unselfish, loving choices made by birthparents.  I also don’t know how to put it into words.  You did it beautifully.

By lovebeingamom2 on Monday, March 19, 2012 at 5:33 pm.

Hey, that original post was mine! I was so glad not to be alone in my confusion on how to respond. Your blog really captures my emotions so well. Thank you for doing what I could not do. I’ll learn from it I promise!

By yesimln on Thursday, March 22, 2012 at 7:55 pm.

Yesimin, what a great question to ask in the first place! Thanks for jogging my memory and inspiring me to write the post.

And lovebeingamom2, thanks for reading and your thoughtful comment!

By Barbara Herel on Thursday, March 22, 2012 at 11:08 pm.

This is exactly how i feel as well.. thank you for posting this, i always feel that i get put out as a hero, i am nothing more than woman that just wanted to be a mother so badly, i felt we where by far the lucky ones, considering we played for a child and got blessed with 3 in total through foster/adopt, yes as i learn more about my kids previous life, i do understand that wouldve not made it long in that life style at all, but i am so lucky every single day to have them in my life and love them with everything, just tell ppl when they tell me “how lucky they are to have you”, i say it goes both ways, we are egually as lucky here.

By mamatasha on Sunday, March 25, 2012 at 12:00 am.

Thank You for sharing….This is exactly how we feel. We get this all the time. Someone comes up to us and tells us that our kids are so… lucky to be in our family. Sometimes I get so upset because we feel that we are the lucky ones. People don’t understand. Our kids have changed our live for the good…                                                      My husband and I are also foster/adopt parents of special need children and we also got to know the birth parents and their family. Our kid’s previous lives were not good, but the birhtparents and family did love them very much.It was only due to unselfish love from the birth familys that they are now in our family. So much emotions on both sides, but we Thank God very day that he has blessed us with our children.

By Roseann & Tom H. on Thursday, April 05, 2012 at 2:30 pm.

We get this all the time, too, and I reply “no, we are lucky to have these kids”.  I have been saying this for almost three years, and it may finally be paying off.  Yesterday when our neighbor saw the four of us walking together he said “what a lucky family!”  wink

By jszmom on Monday, April 09, 2012 at 12:46 pm.

It’s good to know there are so many lucky families out there! Thanks for your comments, ladies!

By Barbara Herel on Thursday, April 12, 2012 at 2:04 pm.
Newer comments >>

Post a Comment

{headline}

Commenting is available to registered members only. Please log in or create an account.

Meet the Author

Barbara Herel

Barbara Herel

New York

I have recently adopted or am adopting from...
U.S. Newborn

View Profile »


Recent Adoption Blog Comments